Review: 2018 Amaze vs Dzire vs Ameo diesel-automatic comparison

Well suited to India as diesel-automatic cars may be, there’s a genuine dearth of ‘mass market’ options around. It’s welcome news, then, that the second-gen Honda Amaze has been launched with the option of a diesel engine that gets a continuously variable transmission (CVT). A diesel-CVT is not only unique to the compact sedan segment in India but it’s also a first for Honda globally. What’s more, the car is not prohibitively expensive either. Prices for the Honda Amaze diesel-automatic range from Rs 8.39-8.99 lakh (ex-showroom, Delhi).

Best alternatives for the Honda Amaze diesel-automatic come in the form of the Maruti Dzire DDiS 190 AGS (Rs 7.9-9.43 lakh) and the Volkswagen Ameo TDI DSG (Rs 9.2-10.02 lakh). The interesting bit is where the Amaze uses a CVT, the Dzire comes with a five-speed automated manual transmission (AMT), while the Ameo sports a seven-speed dual-clutch arrangement. In a sense, this comparison is almost as much about the gearboxes as it is about the cars in their entirety. We’re out to zero in on the model that offers the most in terms of convenience, comfort and practicality.

Dimensions
	Honda Amaze V CVT	Maruti Suzuki Dzire ZDi+ AGS	Volkswagen Ameo DSG Highline Plus
Length	3995mm	3995mm	3995mm
Width	1695mm	1735mm	1682mm
Height	1501mm	1515mm	1483mm
Wheelbase	2470mm	2450mm	2470mm
Boot space	420 litres	378 litres	330 litres
Fuel tank	35 litres	37 litres	45 litres
Tyre size	175/65 R15	185/65 R15	185/60 R15
Kerb weight	1039kg	990kg	1184kg

What are they like to drive?

Like its predecessor, the second-gen Amaze too features Honda’s wide-serving 1.5-litre i-DTEC diesel engine. But where this engine makes 100hp and 200Nm in the other Hondas – the new Amaze diesel-manual included – it’s been detuned substantially to produce 80hp and 160Nm in this application. Honda says this has been done to preserve the life of the CVT. Honestly, though, you don’t feel any shortage of power on the go. The CVT beautifully complements the Honda diesel engine’s legendary tractability, and the result is a smooth build up of speed at mild throttle inputs. The Amaze diesel-CVT feels right at home in the thick of city traffic as well as out cruising on the highway. What’s missing though are paddleshifters (the Amaze petrol-CVT gets them) and there’s no option for manual inputs via the gear lever either. ‘S’ mode on the gearbox does make the engine more responsive, and there’s a ‘Low’ mode, too, that comes handy in the hills.

We were pleasantly surprised to find the Amaze the quickest (or a close second) in our kickdown acceleration runs. Overtaking poses no problem, but you do get a bit of the CVT-typical rubberband effect when you ask more of the engine. At this time, the i-DTEC unit gets noisy and raucous enough to make you think Honda’s efforts to enhance overall refinement have only met with partial success.

It is quite telling that the Dzire’s diesel engine (not known for its refinement) is the quietest unit in this comparison. The engine in question is the Fiat-sourced and Maruti-branded 1.3-litre DDiS 190. Its 75hp is the lowest of this trio, but its 190Nm of torque is par for the course for this class of car. As ever, the engine exhibits some bottom-end lag, followed by reasonable punch around 2,000rpm. However, in the case of the Dzire diesel-AMT, your driving style will not be dictated by the engine’s characteristics but by those of the gearbox. At part-throttle inputs, the AMT goes about the business of swapping cogs quite effectively. Weigh down heavier on the throttle pedal though, and the AMT will often respond with an untimely shift. A workaround to this issue is to use the gear lever to manually change gears, say when you want to overtake. Still, there’s no getting around the head nod that results from the long pause between shifts. The relatively long shift times also reflect in the Dzire’s slow kickdown acceleration times. Also, you’ll have to be careful when starting out on an incline; the Dzire AMT has a tendency to roll back before the gearbox hooks up properly.  

On paper, it’s the Ameo that has the best specifications. Its 1.5-litre diesel engine makes a strong 110hp and 250Nm, and the seven-speed dual-clutch gearbox is as sophisticated as they come. Like the other two cars here, the Ameo creeps forward smoothly in bumper-to-bumper traffic scenarios. However, when speeds start to increase, you’ll note the engine is a bit sluggish in its initial response; shifting to the gearbox’s ‘S’ mode does help here. The fact is that the 1.5 TDI engine only gets into its prime at about 1,800rpm, at which point it also transforms into something much more energetic. There’s a thick slug of torque from 2,500-4,500rpm and it makes overtaking on the highway a cinch. What also works really well is the gearbox. Automatic shifts are timely and fast but the real fun is in flicking up and down the ratios via the gear lever in manual mode. You can feel the shifts every now and then and it’s not as smooth as the Amaze’s CVT, but the Ameo’s twin-clutch arrangement certainly does more for the enthusiastic driver. Where the Ameo doesn’t impress is in engine refinement, with a particularly loud clatter at idle.

Unfortunately, we couldn’t test the three cars for fuel economy. While all cars promise to be efficient, claimed figures suggest the Dzire will stretch each litre of diesel the farthest. The Dzire AMT has been certified with an exceptional fuel economy figure of 28.4kpl, which is significantly more than the Amaze CVT’s 23.8kpl and Ameo TDI DSG’s 21.73kpl.

Powertrain and performance
	Honda Amaze V CVT	Maruti Suzuki Dzire ZDi+ AGS	Volkswagen Ameo DSG Highline Plus
Engine	1498cc, 4 cyls	1248cc, 4 cyls	1498cc, 4 cyls
Power	80hp at 3600rpm	75hp at 4000rpm	110hp at 4000rpm
Torque	160Nm at 1750rpm	190Nm at 2000rpm	250Nm at 1500-3000rpm
Transmission	CVT	5-speed AMT	7-speed dual-clutch
0-20kph	1.28s	1.20s	1.94s
0-40kph	2.89s	3.38s	3.39s
0-60kph	4.94s	5.55s	5.61s
0-80kph	7.80s	9.23s	8.20s
0-100kph	11.75s	13.99s	11.98s
0-120kph	17.24s	20.10s	16.89s
0-140kph	25.37s	30.04s	24.11s
20-80kph (in kickdown)	6.12s	7.90s	6.27s
40-100kph (in kickdown)	9.06s	11.16s	8.80s
Noise at idle	46.7dB	45.3dB	49.9dB
Noise at 50kph	65.4dB	61.8dB	63.2dB
Noise at 80kph	67.2dB	65.1dB	67.1dB

How do they compare on ride and handling?

You get a good feel for the road at the Amaze’s helm. The steering is relatively light but also quite precise, making this a reasonably fun car in the corners. The Amaze is softer sprung than its rivals which helps make it that little bit more absorbent of bumps and potholes in town. On the flip side, when you up the pace, there’s more up and down movement too.

The Dzire feels better tied down than the Amaze on the highway. Its suspension setup is actually quite well judged, but what lets the Dzire down is the steering. It weights up inconsistently and offers little by way of feedback at high speeds. And, around town, the woefully inadequate self-centering calls for a firm hand on the wheel at all times.

It’s the Ameo that gives the most confidence. The VW feels sure-footed at all times, it isn’t as affected by strong crosswinds as the lighter Amaze and Dzire and, in general, drives like a bigger car. You also get reasonable connect from the steering at all times. It does feel firm in its setup relative to the other two, but you really won’t have reason to complain in the manner in which it tackles the rough stuff. Do note, our test car came equipped with 15-inch rims. The Ameo can also be had with 16-inchers, though the enhanced look of the larger wheels is sure to compromise ride comfort.

What are they like on the inside?

Remember how spartan the original Amaze looked on the inside? Thankfully, that’s not something you’ll think about the new car’s cabin. The new Amaze’s dual-tone dashboard is well styled, even if the absence of a touchscreen on this diesel-automatic variant does rob it of some modernity. Material quality is hugely improved too, with a nice textured finish to many of the surfaces and buttons. Do note, many new Amaze owners have reported a misaligned glovebox lid that pops open when driving over potholes and the like. What does enhance the look of things in the cabin are the new front seats. They are not only richer in looks but also offer excellent shoulder support and get adjustable headrests – something the old Amaze lacked.

You’ll be well catered to on the Maruti Dzire’s large (if soft) front seats too. What stands out in the Dzire’s cabin is the sense of space; it just doesn’t feel like a compact sedan on the inside. Maruti has also done its bit to uplift the ambience with extensive use of light materials and faux wood. The problem is that the beige seat fabrics and carpets are prone to getting dirty quick, and the wood finish is passé. That said, the dash is neat in look, the dials look classy and the flat-bottomed steering wheel is decidedly sporty.

A flat-bottomed steering is something you’ll also find in the Ameo’s familiar cabin. But more than anything else, it’s the quality of the package that will win you over. There’s a solid thunk on door shut, the switchgear feels chunky and there’s a certain richness to even bits like the sun visors. It feels like a German car alright. For all its quality, however, there’s no getting around the fact that this is not a roomy cabin. Tilt and telescopic steering adjust makes it easy to find a good driving position and the large front seats are comfy, but you sit close to the co-driver and the driver environment isn’t spacious.

The gap to rivals just increases when you move to the rear. Legroom in the VW is very limited, the cabin isn’t wide enough to seat three abreast in comfort and there’s no centre armrest either. Rear seat passengers in the Amaze have it much nicer. There’s generous legroom, the cabin feels wide and the rear seat is well designed. Taller passengers might find headroom limited, and will get little support from the small, fixed headrests though. A higher-set centre armrest would have helped, as would a dedicated air con vent at the back, though we did find cooling to be effective enough. Those seated on the back seat of the Dzire will find thigh support to be insufficient and that the rear air con protrudes a bit far back, but that’s largely it. There’s a surprising amount of legroom and comfort levels are quite good.

Equipment and safety
	Honda Amaze V CVT	Maruti Suzuki Dzire ZDi+ AGS	Volkswagen Ameo DSG Highline Plus
LED headlights	NA	Yes	NA
Auto headlamps/wipers	NA/NA	Yes/NA	NA/Yes
Keyless go	Yes	Yes	NA
Cruise control	NA	NA	Yes
Android Auto/Apple CarPlay	NA	Yes/Yes	Yes/Yes
Auto-dimming mirror	NA	Yes	Yes
Rear air con vents	NA	Yes	Yes
Adjustable rear headrests	NA	Yes	Yes
Rear parking sensors/camera	Yes/NA	Yes/Yes	Yes/Yes
ESP	NA	NA	Yes
Airbags	2	2	2
Price (ex-showroom, Delhi)	Rs 8.99 lakh	Rs 9.43 lakh	Rs 10.02 lakh

How do they compare on features?

Irrespective of the trim you buy these diesel-automatic compact sedans in, you are assured of basic safety kit. All three models get dual front airbags and anti-lock brakes as standard. The Ameo misses out on Isofix child-seat mounts at the rear but somewhat makes amends with standard-fit electronic stability control and hill hold control.

In terms of comfort and convenience features, the Amaze trails its rivals. Honda’s decision to leave out the full-spec VX trim for the Amaze diesel-automatic means its compact sedan is the only one here without a touchscreen infotainment system and a rear-view camera, and there’s no provision for rear air con vents altogether. The fully loaded Dzire ZDi+ does quite well for itself when talking features and is the only one here with full LED headlights (with auto on/off). Features exclusive to the VW Ameo Highline Plus include auto wipers, cruise control, auto-dimming interior mirror and one-touch operation for all four power windows. The Ameo does miss out on some frills like keyless entry, push-button start and LED daytime-running lights, though.

In the battle of the infotainment systems, it’s the Maruti’s SmartPlay touchscreen unit that comes up trumps. It comes bundled with Android Auto, Apple CarPlay and MirrorLink, and features onboard navigation as well. The Ameo’s touchscreen unit runs the Dzire’s close on features but feels a bit last-gen. Amaze diesel-automatic buyers have to make do with a simpler 2 DIN audio system though aux-in, USB and Bluetooth for audio and telephone functions are included.

What are they like on the outside?

And finally the way these cars look. The first-gen Honda Amaze was one of the first models that managed to get the proportions right for a compact sedan. The new one is even better turned out. It’s built around a 65mm larger wheelbase, is marginally wider and sports wider tracks too. In all, it looks more wholesome than the old Amaze, and that definitely is a big plus. Styling is neat but the bluff, chrome-heavy nose does tend to divide opinion.

The new Dzire, on the other hand, is slightly less polarising in its appearance. There’s a good balance to the shape and it even manages to look quite substantial. Chrome embellishments at the front and LED headlights give it a premium look but not everyone is a fan of that face.

Where the new Amaze and Dzire are built on platforms developed to support a compact sedan, the Ameo was never envisioned to be a product off VW’s PQ25 platform that underpins the Polo. That should explain why the made-for-India Ameo looks the way it does. The proportions are awkward and the tail section looks like the afterthought it is. The rest of the car, though, is smart in look, even with the 15-inch rims.

In terms of luggage capacity, the Amaze has bragging rights with its segment-best 420-litre boot. You can fit in quite a bit into the Dzire’s 378-litre boot as well; though we did find the Ameo’s well-finished 330-litre boot better shaped and more usable. The Ameo is also the only one that offers rear seat fold to let you fit in more baggage.

Which one should I buy?

As you may have derived, each of these cars has its set of strengths and weaknesses. Your pick of the three would boil down to the weightage you give individual factors.

The Maruti Suzuki Dzire has the roomiest cabin, an expansive features set and also comes with the promise of excellent fuel economy. All well, but in a comparison centred around the automatic transmission, what spoils it for this version of the Dzire is its gearbox. The AMT feels just too basic when judged in light of the Amaze’s CVT and Ameo’s dual-clutch units.

Frequent highway users will find a great long-distance machine in the Volkswagen Ameo TDI DSG. Its punchy engine, quick-shifting gearbox and great high-speed manners – it has all the right ingredients. The strong build and impressive quality also further the Ameo’s case. It is slightly pricey and down on space to rivals, but for someone with limited use for the rear seats, the VW does make for a great buy.

But, in our book, it is the Honda Amaze that comes closest to being an all-rounder. It’s got a pleasant engine-gearbox combo, has a spacious cabin and scores well on overall comfort. Sure, the engine is noisy but fact is neither of its rivals are much better off on that front. However, a few vital feature additions would make the Amaze a more wholesome package. Then again, factor in the fair money Honda wants for one and you’ll see the Amaze as the right choice. Honda’s diesel-CVT adventure sure has got off to the right start.

from Autocar India - Cars https://ift.tt/2mo1iGC
via IFTTT